ergo-log.com

Definition: "An ergogenic aid is any substance or phenomenon that enhances performance "

about us

/

contact

/

08.09.2014


Court hearing for CrossFit researchers

The American sports scientists Steven Devor and Michael Smith are being taken to court. In November 2013 they published a study on the effects of 10 weeks of CrossFit training and the owner of the gym where the study was done is not happy with it.

CrossFit makes you fitter
After a quick flip through Smith and Devor's study you might wonder why a court case is necessary [scribd.com]. At first sight it's pure advertising for CrossFit.

The researchers followed a group of 23 men and 20 women who did CrossFit training almost every day. The subjects became slimmer, more muscled and fitter. The first figure below shows the men's progression, the second that of the women. By the way, all the subjects were also on a paleo diet.


Court hearing for CrossFit researchers


Court hearing for CrossFit researchers


It's interesting that CrossFit was effective for all participants. Those who started off in terrible condition became fitter, but participants who were already fit also became fitter. Overweight participants lost weight, as did participants who already had a healthy body fat percentage.


Court hearing for CrossFit researchers


Court hearing for CrossFit researchers


Injuries
The reason that the owner of the CrossFit gym took the researchers to court is one short sentence in the study about participants who dropped out.

"Of the 11 subjects who dropped out of the training program, 2 cited time concerns with the remaining 9 subjects (16% of total recruited subjects) citing overuse or injury for failing to complete the program and finish follow-up testing", the researchers write.

Raw nerve
This comment touched a raw nerve in the CrossFit movement. CrossFitters are already at loggerheads with sports scientists who say that CrossFit is too demanding for most people who do this form of fitness training. The training programmes include too many exercises that are quite difficult to perform, and the short amount of time devoted to each exercise means that CrossFit workouts don't give participants enough time to prepare their body for the to-failure type exertion that CrossFit promotes. [Curr Sports Med Rep. 2011 Nov-Dec;10(6):383-9.]

In the last few years there have been several reports in the American media about accidents and injuries from people doing CrossFit training, and CrossFit is not happy with this negative publicity either. It seems that Devor and Smith's study in the Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research is the last straw for CrossFit.

Conclusion
"To our knowledge, no research on the aerobic benefits of high-intensity power training [this is how the researchers describe CrossFit training] has been conducted", the researchers write. "High-intensity power training focuses on high intensity resistance training using multiple joint exercises, with little to no focus on traditional aerobic activities. Despite this, our results show that this type of training also provides aerobic and body composition benefits."

"Based on the results presented here, individuals of all fitness levels and either gender can realize body composition and aerobic benefits from high-intensity power training. Given that our subjects were following a Paleolithic diet, we cannot relate all of the observed weight loss to high-intensity power training. However, high-intensity power training and Paleolithic diet in combination could be used to promote positive changes in body composition."

Source:
J Strength Cond Res. 2013 Nov;27(11):3159-72.

More:
CrossFit is more fun for beginners, but not more effective than traditional fitness 24.08.2014