ergo-log.com

Definition: "An ergogenic aid is any substance or phenomenon that enhances performance "

about us

/

contact

/

17.04.2013


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones

Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones
After a workout muscles recover and grow faster the more amino acids they can absorb from the blood. That's why so many strength athletes drink a shake with whey or another easily absorbed protein after working out. Sports scientists at McMaster University in Canada have discovered that strength athletes benefit more from ingesting the whey in one large portion than in several small ones.

There are indications that proteins have a strong anabolic effect in elderly people if you administer them in concentrated form: to start with you deny your body protein for a number of hours and then you give it a couple of dozen grams at once. We've written about this here, here and here.



Research on protein pulse feeding is popular among athletes who believe in intermittent fasting. Logical, as an increased anabolic effect from a concentrated administration of protein meshes seamlessly with the idea of intermittent fasting.

The Canadians make no comment about intermittent fasting or protein pulsing. Their article is more fundamental.

The researchers got male students to train their upper leg with 8 sets of 10 reps on a leg extension machine and then gave the students proteins. Half of the students were immediately given a giant-size shake containing 25 g whey [BOLUS], the other half were given a mini-shake every 20 minutes containing 2.5 g whey [PULSE]. [A little confusing as we just talked about protein pulses: our apologies.]

The set up for the experiment is shown below.


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones


Throughout the 320 minutes that the researchers monitored the students' blood they found the same amounts of essential amino acids [below left] and leucine [below right] in both the 25 g group and the 10 X 2.5 g group.


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones


But over time there's a clear difference: in the 25 g group [BOLUS] you can see that there was a peak in the essential amino acid and leucine concentration an hour after intake. In the 10 X 2.5 g group [PULSE] there’s no peak.

The excessive amount of essential amino acids and leucine stimulates the production of muscle fibre protein [Myofibrillar FSR] the Canadians discovered when they studied samples of muscle tissue from the subjects.


Post workout: your muscles benefit more from one large portion of whey than ten small ones


"In conclusion, we report that BOLUS after resistance exercise is more effective in stimulating myofibrillar protein synthesis than is PULSE", the researchers conclude. "The greater myofibrillar protein synthesis response after BOLUS was associated with greater acute phosphorylation of anabolic signaling proteins that regulate translation initiation. The rapid rise in extracellular essential amino acid concentrations, or possibly of leucine alone, that occurred after BOLUS appears to underpin the greater signal activation and protein synthetic response that are observed after an acute bout of resistance exercise."

Source:
Am J Clin Nutr. 2011 Sep;94(3):795-803.

More:
Portion of meat post workout stimulates muscle growth 04.04.2013
Mix of casein, whey and soya protein works better than whey alone after strength training 07.03.2013
Training with light weights also boosts anabolic effect of protein supplementation 09.10.2012
Older strength athlete benefits more from whey than from soya after a workout 20.08.2012
Older strength sports athletes need more whey after training 19.08.2012
Protein helps muscles grow faster up to 24 hours after strength training 16.06.2011
BCAAs still useful even if you already use protein supplements 18.02.2011
The combined effect of whey, creatine and glucose 02.02.2011
Best post-workout shake? Whey and casein cocktail 17.12.2010
Fast protein snack after training? There's room for improvement 06.12.2010
Five months of strength training with and without whey 04.12.2010
Whey is more effective before a workout than after 02.12.2010
Why it's okay to take fish oil capsules at the same time as a protein shake 04.11.2010
Soya protein and casein equally good for muscles 25.09.2010
Pre-digested protein during workout stimulates muscle growth 16.07.2010
The effect of a litre of skimmed milk after a workout 30.06.2010
Soya protein and whey mix makes best pre-workout shake 15.04.2010
Eighteen grams of whey before training increases your fat burning 12.01.2010
Casein shake just before training doesn't work well 16.10.2009
Optimal protein dose after weight training is twenty grams 19.12.2008