ergo-log.com

Definition: "An ergogenic aid is any substance or phenomenon that enhances performance "

about us

/

contact

/

09.05.2018


Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells

Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells
If you do not have any weights at hand, but still want to perform flyes and reverse flyes, take a look at the study that sports scientists at the Norwegian University of Science and Technology published in the Journal of Human Kinetics. According to this research you can perform these exercises with an elastic band instead of free weights. However, exercises with an elastic band stimulate the chest muscles and rear delts a little bit less than exercises with dumbbells.

Study
The Norwegians had 29 test subjects perform the fly and the reverse-fly with a load with just 10 reps possible. On one occasion, the subjects performed the exercises with dumbbells, the other time with elastic bands.


Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells


Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells



The researchers placed electrodes on the skin of the test subjects with which they could see how hard the muscles underneath had to work.

Results
In the figures below, the researchers cut the concentric and eccentric parts of the movement into two halves [CON1 and CON2, ECC1 and ECC2].

In general, both versions of the flyes and the reverse flyes have approximately the same effect on the pectoralis major and the posterior deltoid, respectively. But if you look more precisely, you will see that the dumbbell exercises provide a bit stronger stimuli than the elastic band exercises.

On the other hand, the stimulation of the supporting muscle groups during flyes and reverse flyes, such as the anterior deltoid and the deltoid medius at the reverse flyes, is greater when the subjects used an elastic band.


Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells


Flyes and reverse flyes: an elastic band instead of dumbbells



Conclusion
"In conclusion, elastic resistance bands induced slightly lower muscle activity in the muscles most people aim to activate during flyes and reverse flyes, i.e., pectoralis major and deltoideus posterior, respectively", the Norwegians write.

"However, elastic resistance bands increased the muscle activation level substantially in the deltoideus anterior in flyes, and deltoideus medius and trapezius descendens in reverse flyes, possibly due to elastic bands being a more unstable resistance modality."

"Overall, the results show that elastic resistance bands can be considered a feasible alternative to dumbbells in flyes and reverse flyes."

Source:
J Hum Kinet. 2018 Mar 23;61:5-13.

More:
What's better? Twists with a machine or an elastic band? 28.12.2016
Training shoulders with elastic band just as effective as using weights 08.10.2014
Push-ups with elastic bands just as good as bench presses for strength building 11.08.2014

Archives:
Resistance Training
Elastic Band


Squats with a flexible bar: a lot of impact on muscles with relatively little weight
If you squat with a flexible bar made of plastic instead of steel, you can stimulate your muscles using relatively little weight in a way that normally would require much heavier weights.

The narrow-grip version of the bench press stimulates the pecs just as well as the regular bench press
Shoulders injuries in strength sports often implicate that bench presses are no longer an option. Bench presses are just too stressful for their shoulder joint. But that does not mean that they can not train their upper body properly.

Sadistic variants of the pull-up are just as good for your muscles as the humane version
Extremely difficult variants of the pull-up do not stimulate your lats better than the regular version.