ergo-log.com

Definition: "An ergogenic aid is any substance or phenomenon that enhances performance "

about us

/

contact

/

17.01.2011


More than half a kg weight loss per week makes you catabolic

If athletic women want to lose weight they are probably better off confining the weight loss to a pound a week. Finnish sports scientists at the University of Jyvaskyla discovered that testosterone levels take a dive if weight loss is faster.

The researchers did an experiment with 15 women with an average age of 28 years. The women had all been training for at least six months, using weights and doing aerobics. They were put on a diet for 4 weeks that included a daily 1.4 g protein per kg bodyweight.

Half of the women ate 1100 kcal less daily than the women burned. On a diet like this you’ll lose 1 kg a week in theory. The other half of the women ate 550 kcal less daily than the women burned. This is a diet that in theory results in half a kilogram weight loss per week.

And indeed. When the 4 weeks were up, the 1KG group had lost 3.9 kg, and the 0.5KG group had lost 2.2 kg. The effect on total bodyweight is shown below.

As a result of their training and protein-rich diet the women lost almost no lean body mass. The 1KG group lost 3.8 kg fat and the 0.5KG group lost 2.0 kg fat. The second figure below shows the effect of the diet on the fat mass.







The training results remained the same for both groups, except for one thing: because the women became lighter they were able to jump higher.

But the women in the 1KG group felt worse than the women in the 0.5KG group. They reported more often feeling sleepy and tired. Their testosterone levels went down dramatically.



The more weight the women lost per week, the more their testosterone levels plummeted.



The researchers write that women are better off losing weight slowly rather than too fast. You need to be alert in daily life, and hormonal changes like this probably have negative effects.

"A weight reduction of 0.5 kg per week with ~1.4 g protein/kg/day can be recommended to normal weighted, physically active women instead of a larger weight reduction, because the latter may lead to a catabolic hormonal state", the Finns conclude.

Source:
J Int Soc Sports Nutr. 2010 Jan 25;7(1):4.

More:
Fat belly neutralises DHT 29.12.2010
Dieting is stressful all round 20.10.2010
Lean mass recovers quicker after fasting than fat mass: animal study 18.10.2010
Crash diet damages digestive system, not muscles: animal study 17.10.2010
Bulimia programmes body for obesity 19.09.2010
Lose weight but keep good humoured with protein-rich diet 06.04.2010
Strict diet reduces post-exercise energy burning 28.12.2009
Dieting bodybuilders retain muscle with high protein foods 18.12.2009
Constant fight against appetite reduces life expectancy 09.11.2009
GHB’s little brother makes low-carb diet enjoyable 13.08.2009